Aperture 3 aka Aperture X
As many of you may have heard over the last week or so a book appeared on Amazon that had Aperture X in the title. It was available for pre-order with availability in the Spring of 2010. This has led to a lot of chatter about an imminent release of the next major version of Aperture. The word on the street is the release will be rebranded as Aperture X to align it with OS X or something like that.
While I have no specific knowledge of Apple’s release plans or naming strategy I have heard from a lot of sources that I consider reliable that we will be getting a major Aperture update very very soon. This wouldn’t surprise me at all and I hope soon means this year. Just so we can all see what it does, make our decisions on what software we use. and get on with our work. I thought that I would share a couple of my own thoughts on Aperture versus Lightroom and my own plans, considering I answer that question either in person or via email about 100 times a day.
To make a long story short – I plan to stick with Aperture for the foreseeable future for my own use. The only way that I would switch to Lightroom is if there were such significant features and improvements released by Adobe that it would actually make my life better, save me a lot of time, and cause me to enjoy spending time in Lightroom. You heard that right – I know Lightroom very well, I think it is a great piece of software, but I do not enjoy it at all. I actually enjoy organizing in Aperture. For what I do and what I care about Aperture still leaves Lightroom in the dust. When working with my photos in Lightroom I feel boxed in or something. I really do not like the separate library, develop, etc modes in Lightroom. I do not think that a lot of the organizational tools are all that flexible or thought out, stacks are virtually useless, etc.
This may surprise you considering how much I complain about default NEF processing in Aperture among other things but those things are minor compared to how slow working in Lightroom is for me. I am glad that Adobe released the Lightroom 3 beta – there is nothing that I want or better said  - nothing revolutionary that causes me to want to switch. My commitment to Aperture (for my personal photography and my personal library) is solid and if any of you were wondering – as soon as Aperture 3 or Aperture X hits the streets I will have it and will continue trying to explain the best way to use it to all of the loyal readers out there.
Here is a promise – when it comes out I will dedicate 100% of my focus to update and expand my Aperture guides to be better, stronger, and include all of the Aperture X/Aperture 3 goodness as soon as it is humanly possible to produce with a degree of quality and accuracy that I am comfortable with.
RB
Ps. Obviously the only other reason I would switch is if Apple themselves made it very clear there was no Aperture future – as in the product is cancelled.





I worry about a new version because I still have a very good G5 PowerPC 2.3Ghz with 6GB RAM. Do you think that Apple will shun the older machines out there?
Roman,
I am sorry to say that the trend with Apple is Intel only lately. You can obviously continue to run Aperture 2 on your machine and maybe Aperture X will support PowerPC but…. I doubt it. If we assume that it will use Snow Leopard’s new found 64bit-ness and other technologies it will either require Snow Leopard or be way better on Snow Leopard. So even if it somehow degrades gracefully to pre-snow-leopard technology you probably won[t really want to use it.
If Aperture2 and your current setup is doing just fine – don’t change anything – you don’t have to go with the new stuff. However the performance I am seeing on my newest Intel machines is so fantastic I cannot even bear to run my G5 any more – really, the only reason it still exists is because I am a cheap skate and do not want to pay to upgrade my scanning software to Snow Leopard so it is still running tiger with the sole purpose of running one of my many film scanners.
RB
“Here is a promise – when it comes out I will dedicate 100% of my focus to update and expand my Aperture guides to be better, stronger, and include all of the Aperture X/Aperture 3 goodness as soon as it is humanly possible to produce with a degree of quality and accuracy that I am comfortable with.”
Thanks, it looks like there will be an even greater need for this now that AUN or AUPN has totally collapsed into the disaster called MacCreate. The only place I know to discuss Aperture issues now is the Apple forums. Do you know of any other?
Rob
Rob, check out the Mac forum in dpreview. There’s an active discussion of all things Mac, including Aperture, for the professional or prosumer photographer.
Looking forward to Aperture X!
Thanks, Matt. I’ll check it out.
Hey RB, please include my email in your mailing list when your new guides are up. It would be cool to see what happens if you put up a forum on your site too. I really like what you have to say. down to earth, professional and honest. All these other forums are turning into social networking sites, and we don’t really need another one of those.